Q3 global power and utility deals hit by valuation concerns

  • Share

London, 15 November 2012 – Following a bumper Q2 of deal-making in the global power and utilities (P&U) sector, Q3 saw mergers and acquisitions (M&A) values in the sector decline by 60% (68 compared to 77 in Q2) and volumes of activity down by 12% (US$19b compared to US$47.9b in Q2), as the growing valuation gap between buyers and sellers proves the major barrier to deal completions, together with a significant decline in European and Asia-Pacific deal activity. That is according to EY’s quarterly Power Transactions and Trends report, released today.

Unlike last quarter, which witnessed eight billion-dollar-plus deals (including four over US$3b), Q3 2012 saw only four deals over a billion dollars. Average deal value was US$352m, a decline of 59% compared to Q2 2012.

M&A value for the year has only reached US$92.9b so far and it looks set that 2012 M&A will fall short of the US$144.7b achieved in 2011.

Joseph Fontana, EY Global Transaction Advisory Power and Utilities Leader, says:

“The fall-off in deal activity can be largely attributed to renewed global economic uncertainty, delays in privatization and divestment programs in Europe, as well as a growing valuation gap between buyers and sellers, which has led to failed deal discussions. Although divestments and unbundling requirements in Europe will keep Asian investors active in the coming quarter, the fear of not getting the right valuations might drive sellers to hold on to their assets, and continue to restrict M&A activity.” 

US on the rise while European dominance ends

Europe’s long dominance over global P&U deal value ended in Q3 2012, with transaction value declining 71% compared to Q2 and 64% compared to the same period last year.  Americas, on the other hand, saw deal volume more than double compared to the previous quarter, while value increased 66% compared to Q2 and over 100% on Q3 2011, driven by large generation segment deals in the US.

Fontana says: “Europe witnessed several failed deal discussions between buyers and sellers due to a combination of asset valuation gaps and some tougher financing conditions in Western Europe. The ripple effect was seen on Asia-Pacific deal activity, whose investors, specifically Asian funds, are the likely buyers of European utility assets.

“Despite the challenges, we expect European M&A to regain momentum, driven by announced company divestments and government privatization programs, albeit at a potentially slower pace than originally expected. Greek and Czech privatizations seem to be moving forward and may land in the next quarter or two.”

Generation and waste management driving deals

Renewed interest in the Americas generation sector made it a dominant sector segment in Q3 2012, with value up by 45% on the previous quarter. Renewables deal value was down 19% on the previous quarter due to the absence of large value deals, however, deal volume was up 7% on the back of a rise in wind energy transactions. Waste management transactions drove the overall deal activity of the segment contributing over 55% to the total deal value, led by Veolia’s US$1.9b divestment of Veolia ES Solid Waste, Inc. to US-based Star Atlantic Waste Holdings, LP.

Deal sizes to fall in next 12 months

Looking ahead, EY’s newly released Capital Confidence Barometer for Power & Utilities, a survey of over 1500 global executives on M&A appetite, which included 171 respondents from the sector, shows 80% of power and utility executives think the global economy shows no signs of improvement and large transformation deals are off the table, with 79% of power and utilities executives saying the size of any M&A they do in the coming year will be below US$500m.

Fontana says: “Declining global economic confidence is a key barrier to the execution of the billion-dollar deals, and until we see clearer resolutions in Europe, greater transparency of Chinese growth, and a rebound in the US labor and housing market, we are unlikely to see the mega-deals return.”

A valuation gap between buyers and sellers is the key deterrent to M&A with 38% of sector respondents citing the valuation gap between buyers and sellers at 10–20%; 66% believe it is greater than 10%.

Prioritization of growth has declined for power and utility executives around the globe. Despite remaining a primary goal (40% say it’s their focus), the percentage of power and utilities executives focusing on growth has fallen to 40% from 48% six months ago and 71% two years ago. In its place is a renewed focus on fundamentals of reducing costs and improving efficiency, particularly in the Eurozone and parts of Asia-Pacific.

Global outlook

Fontana concludes: “We have a stand-off between buyers and sellers. Buyers think assets are overpriced, and the sellers are less willing to divest. It remains to be seen who will blink first.

“However, there is general consensus that the market is stable. The fundamentals are in place for transactions that make strategic sense. The big deals might be on the back burner for now, but we still anticipate robust activity from financial buyers and the potential for some big mergers where it strategically makes sense. With reasonable credit availability and stockpiled cash, M&A in this industry is not dead — it’s just playing a waiting game.”


Notes to Editors

About the surveys

Power Transactions and Trends Quarterly is based on EY’s analysis of Mergermarket data from 1 July 2012 to 30 September 2012. This analysis utilizes standard industrial classification codes in order to categorize deals.  For the purposes of this publication, our definition of power and utilities is only those companies in the generation, transmission and distribution, renewables and other subsectors.

The Global Capital Confidence Barometer is a bi-annual survey of senior executives from large companies around the world, conducted by the Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU). Our panel is composed of select EY clients and contacts and regular EIU contributors. This snapshot of our findings gauges corporate confidence in the economic outlook, and it identifies boardroom trends and practices in the way companies manage their capital agenda.

Profile of respondents

  • Panel of more than 1,500 executives surveyed in February and March 2012, including 171 power and utility executives (51% from the C-suite)
  • 55% of respondents have revenue of US$1b or more

About EY’s Global Power & Utilities Center

In a world of uncertainty, changing regulatory frameworks and environmental challenges, utility companies need to maintain a secure and reliable supply, while anticipating change and reacting to it quickly. EY's Global Power & Utilities Center brings together a worldwide team of professionals to help you achieve your potential — a team with deep technical experience in providing assurance, tax, transaction and advisory services.

The Center works to anticipate market trends, identify the implications and develop points of view on relevant sector issues. Ultimately it enables us to help you meet your goals and compete more effectively. It’s how EY makes a difference.

About EY

EY is a global leader in assurance, tax, transaction and advisory services. Worldwide, our 167,000 people are united by our shared values and an unwavering commitment to quality. We make a difference by helping our people, our clients and our wider communities achieve their potential.

EY refers to the global organization of member firms of Ernst & Young Global Limited, each of which is a separate legal entity. Ernst & Young Global Limited, a UK company limited by guarantee, does not provide services to clients. For more information about our organization, please visit www.ey.com.

This news release has been issued by EYGM Limited, a member of the global EY organization that also does not provide any services to clients.