Succession and cybersecurity overlooked by Aussie family businesses
Wednesday 3rd June 2015 - Succession planning and cybersecurity are among the top issues facing Australian family businesses today according to a new global report, Staying power: how do family businesses create lasting success?
The report, launched by EY and Kennesaw State University’s Cox Family Enterprise Centre, surveyed 25 of the largest family-owned businesses in each of 21 global markets, including Australia.
EY’s Oceania Family Business Leader, Ian Burgess said family businesses, as an essential source of prosperity and stability to both local and global economies, needed to ensure they weren’t putting their heads in the sand when it came to two critical areas: succession planning and cybersecurity.
“Australian family businesses have a generally positive outlook when it comes to business conditions, with over two-thirds believing that their markets will expand in 2015 and over half expecting to expand their workforce,” Mr Burgess said.
“While it’s heartening that Australian family businesses have a generally positive outlook, they’re behind on two key issues that they should be addressing to ensure their continued sustainability and growth into the next generation and beyond.”
Cyber risk looms large
Australian family businesses are lagging behind their global counterparts when it comes to their awareness of cyber risk. In fact, 41% of Australian family businesses reported having no knowledge of the impact of cyber risk on their company – much higher than the global average of 25%.
Those Australian respondents who were aware of the risks were fairly evenly divided about the scale of its potential impact on their business, with 32% rating it as low and 27% rating it as medium to high.
Mr Burgess said that in an increasingly connected, digital world, family businesses needed to place greater emphasis on their cyber security.
“Even with the near-constant news of cyber breaches, leaks and the resulting financial losses, Australian family businesses seem to be worryingly relaxed about the risk of cyber threats and potential impact on their business.”
“By their nature, family businesses face some particular increased risks beyond the usual hacking and data breaches, such as social media risks, reputational risks and personal safety concerns. For this reason, cybersecurity should be at the top of the agenda for any family business.”
“Around the world, there are thousands of cybersecurity breaches each year – it’s the new reality of doing business. The biggest hurdle to family businesses in this space is recognising the most critical threats and understanding how to address them.”
“The good news is that, due to their concentrated ownership, once family businesses are aware of the risks they have the advantage of being able to make and implement decisions quickly. This allows them to put effective plans in place to help minimise cybersecurity risks,” Mr Burgess said.
EY’s Asia-Pacific Information Security Leader, Mike Trovato said learning to anticipate cyber-crime was critical when it came to organisations transforming themselves from easy targets for cybercriminals to more formidable adversaries.
“Too many organisations fall short of mastering the key components of cybersecurity. Organisations lack focus at the top and the right procedures and practices to anticipate new threats. This is a major concern,” Mr Trovato said.
Planning for the future
EY’s Oceania Leader for Family Office Services, Richard Boyce said that, with half of all the Australian family businesses surveyed still in the hands of the first generation, having a strong and clearly defined succession plan in place is essential to their continuing success
“Succession is arguably the most critical issue a family business has to face, yet it is often one of the most difficult to navigate. Complicated family dynamics and the emotional connection that business leaders and family members feel towards their companies can make addressing the issue a potential minefield,” Mr Boyce said.
“Our survey found that Australian family businesses most commonly left succession planning in the hands of the CEO (42%), followed by owners or family council (32%). This is in contrast to the global results, where 44% of businesses surveyed said their board of directors had primary responsibility for succession planning.”
“If the intention is for the business to remain in family hands, succession must be considered a process, not an endpoint. It needs to be embedded into the day-to-day operations of the business, through training and education of the next generation. Succession is also about creating an enduring business model that can evolve and innovate, therefore the leadership required to be able to last through generational change is far more sophisticated and experienced than ever before.”
“Family members must be willing to address the issue of succession planning head on through an open and ongoing dialogue. Getting this right will free up the CEO, board and council to focus on the wider business,” Mr Boyce said.
Other key survey results at a glance
- 50% of Australian family businesses currently have a first generation leader, 25% second generation, and 13% are led by third and fourth generations.
- Australian family businesses rank lowest in terms of the number of countries they operate in, with an average of 2.3 compared to the global average of 15. In contrast, family businesses based in Germany operate in an average of 39.4 countries, Canada in 13.8 and China in 19.3.
- 90% of Australian respondents are satisfied with the performance of their board of directors, rating it as either good (60%) or excellent (30%).
- Average return on equity for Australian family businesses is 5% - on par with Spain and South Korea.
- Corporate social responsibility and giving back to the community is important to Australian family businesses, with 73% engaged in philanthropic activities.
EY is a global leader in assurance, tax, transaction and advisory services. The insights and quality services we deliver help build trust and confidence in the capital markets and in economies the world over. We develop outstanding leaders who team to deliver on our promises to all of our stakeholders. In so doing, we play a critical role in building a better working world for our people, for our clients and for our communities.
EY refers to the global organization, and may refer to one or more, of the member firms of Ernst & Young Global Limited, each of which is a separate legal entity. Ernst & Young Global Limited, a UK company limited by guarantee, does not provide services to clients. For more information about our organisation, please visit ey.com.
This news release has been issued by Ernst & Young Australia, a member firm of Ernst & Young Global Limited.
Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.