Ecosystems are on the rise
A growing number of organizations are generating value from ecosystem business models.
In the 2021 CEO Imperative Study, 31% of CEOs surveyed indicated that their strategy includes an external ecosystem of business partnerships. The EY Ecosystem Study shows that companies that have embraced ecosystems are generating significant value as a result. The EY study revealed that 69% of business leaders from companies that are part of an ecosystem believe ecosystems are very important to their company’s current success, and 91% agree that ecosystems have increased the resilience of their business. As further evidence of success, compared to the EY ecosystem survey in 2020, these companies are also expanding their use of ecosystems: the average number of relationships has increased from five to seven, with 58% of respondents having more than four active ecosystems.
Further corroborating the increasing strategic importance of ecosystems, many companies are ramping up investment. For example, according to their 2020 annual report, IBM (an EY ecosystem partner) is investing US$1 billion in its hybrid cloud ecosystem so that its partners can play a much bigger role in fulfilling the needs of their clients.
Survey respondents reported that ecosystems are contributing on average 13.7% of total annual revenues, 12.9% in cost reduction and 13.3% in incremental earnings. In some industries, these figures are even higher, with respondents in the telecommunications industry reporting an average of over 16% in both cost reduction and incremental earnings.
Case study: a curated ecosystem to enable self-disruption
Nationwide Insurance required a new brand and a new technology platform to access a customer segment that might otherwise have been unobtainable. Recognizing that its existing approach to innovation and value creation would not be able to deliver the desired results in the required timeframe, Nationwide collaborated with the EY organization to launch Spire, a platform that helps enable customers to get an auto policy issued within minutes in a purely digital experience.
Spire was enabled using EY NexusTM, a digital platform for financial services that runs on Microsoft Azure and has access to an ecosystem of partners whose technologies can be added according to a company’s specific needs.
One of the factors driving the increasing adoption of ecosystem business models is technological improvements. The cloud economy has dramatically lowered the technical and operational hurdles that made ecosystems difficult to set up in the past. In particular, the ability of digital platforms to enable multiple entities to connect through application programming interfaces (APIs) and to iterate quickly and effectively has made ecosystem value easier to develop and offer to end clients.
The ecosystem era has arrived71%
Believe ecosystems are very important to their company’s current success.
How ecosystems are driving transformational growth
Organizations that master ecosystems outperform those that do not across multiple measures.
While the majority of companies that operate an ecosystem are satisfied with the results, we identified a segment of respondents with “high-performing ecosystems”. These ecosystems are more likely than others to drive incremental earnings for their company and adopt best practices in ecosystem management. See our methodology for more details on how we identified high-performing ecosystems.
On average, high-performing ecosystems drive 1.5 times the cost reduction, contribute 1.5 times more to annual revenue, and achieve 2.1 times the incremental revenue growth of low performing ecosystems.
How we identified high-performing ecosystems
To identify respondents with high-performing ecosystems, we looked at two factors: the incremental earnings the ecosystem generated for the company and the company’s adoption of best practices to build and operate an ecosystem. We used advanced statistics (latent class regression) to cluster respondents into groups. This identified three groups of ecosystems with the below characteristics:
- High-performing (37% of respondents): Tend to drive higher incremental earnings and adoption of best practices
- Medium-performing (40%): Tend to drive moderate incremental earnings and adoption of best practices
- Low-performing (23%): Tend to drive low incremental earnings and adoption of best practices
High-performing ecosystems generate significantly more value for their organizations compared to low-performing ecosystems. On average, high-performing ecosystems drive 1.5 times the cost reduction, contribute 1.5 times more to annual revenue, and achieve 2.1 times the incremental revenue growth of low performing ecosystems. This advantage is true across most sectors, with some – such as technology – showing even larger gaps.
Companies with high-performing ecosystems also tend to outperform. In fiscal year 2020, companies with high-performing ecosystems had higher average revenue growth (7.8% for higher-performing vs. 5.4% for low-performing) and net profit margin (10.6% for high-performing vs. 8.1% for low-performing).
Leaders of high-performing ecosystems are more likely to report advantages of ecosystems over traditional approaches in three key areas:
- Growth: Ecosystems drive growth through new joint propositions and access to new geographies, while helping deliver at lower cost reduction
- R&D: Ecosystems provide access to the right assets, talent and expertise which contributes to a higher likelihood of R&D success
- M&A: Ecosystems lead to better business outcomes vs M&A, in part by providing higher growth opportunities and faster execution
Innovation and market transformation
The benefits of ecosystem business models extend far beyond the boundaries of the individual organization and have the potential to impact entire markets and value chains. Over 85% of executives agree that ecosystems are an effective way to connect large companies with small disruptors and foster innovation across value chains and with adjacent industries.
At EY we are seeing this wider impact of ecosystem business models play out in the market as organizations use ecosystems not only to forge new relationships, but also to challenge sector boundaries to innovate at scale. For example, online retailers are partnering with brick-and-mortar stores to offer customers a more convenient experience, and global technology companies are tapping into an innovative ecosystem of start-ups to fuel technology development.
Case study: a blockchain ecosystem game-changer for the gaming industry
Microsoft Xbox’s legacy royalty processing system took 45 days to access validated financial information about royalties earned, a lag that with the related paperwork proved cumbersome to many game publishers, especially the small firms with limited resources.
Microsoft Xbox and EY teams worked together to help transform this system, implementing a transparent blockchain ecosystem that automated the royalty process, reducing the manual effort and operational hours associated with processing royalties for publishers. Creators now have more trust in the process and can focus on creating new games.
Recommendations and next steps for strategic integration of ecosystem business models.
As CEO, how do you ensure your company is best placed to generate value with ecosystem business models? Over 90% of organizations with high-performing ecosystems take at least three of the following actions to source, build and manage their ecosystem relationships:
- Ensuring regular review at the C-suite or board level: when senior management and directors help to drive ecosystem strategy, there is clarity of purpose. (77% of high-performing ecosystems)
- Creating a function that tracks progress: when ecosystems are measured against dedicated KPIs, results improve. (76%)
- Creating a function that identifies potential partnerships: when experts oversee the makeup of an ecosystem, quality ticks up. (74%)
- Allowing ecosystems to operate as a distinct line of business: when ecosystems are given autonomy, they tend to deliver outsized results. (68%)
- Developing a dedicated ecosystem budget: when a company invests in ecosystems as a strategy, things get done in a timely and effective manner. (65%)
- Giving clear ownership to one person: when an ecosystem leader (Chief Ecosystem Officer) is hired, objectives are more likely to be met. (48%)
How EY can help
Of course, the list is not a panacea. Every company will encounter challenges in setting up and maintaining an ecosystem. Three of the most common are:
- Agreeing on common goals and strategy
- Resolving disputes between participants, notably cost and revenue allocation
- Ensuring the ecosystem has the right participants
Another key issue is data interoperability – the ability of systems and services to create, exchange and consume unambiguous data. Differing data privacy regulations, for example, mean this is an ongoing challenge for ecosystem participants.
These issues should be addressed as part of the relationship definition and contractual process, and specific relationship KPIs should be established and assessed during regular reviews to continually optimize your ecosystem’s performance.
As more organizations explore and begin their journey towards business ecosystem value creation, it is also essential that they can understand and identify the correct models to participate in or orchestrate. To help with this first step, recently we identified seven distinct ecosystem business models, each of which has a set of distinguishing attributes and characteristics.
Creating long-term success
With ecosystem business models demonstrating significant operational and performance impact over traditional approaches such as building or buying, a growing cohort of companies across geographies and sectors are making them a strategic imperative.
That being said, ecosystem relationships and business models are technically, operationally, and commercially complex. They also impact every aspect of an enterprise, yet many companies are not structured or culturally aligned to participate in, orchestrate or monetize them. The EY CEO Imperative Study revealed that 88% of CEOs believe the ability to form, lead and manage ecosystems will define successful leadership teams. However, only 48% of survey respondents with high-performing ecosystems indicated they had an ecosystem lead, and when they do, it is usually a functional title that does not guarantee the holder has cross-departmental authority.
Appointing a Chief Ecosystem Officer may be an effective way that companies can overcome the challenges associated with developing successful ecosystems.
Given ecosystems’ increasing strategic importance, there is a clear opportunity for business leaders to refresh their talent strategy and appoint a Chief Ecosystem Officer – an individual at the highest level in the organization who can move ecosystems from a silo to an enterprise-wide growth and value-creation strategy.
Whichever way ecosystems are operationally embraced, for those that make ecosystems a strategic imperative and integrate them into the fabric of how they create value, the rewards can be transformational.
With the number of companies participating in or orchestrating business ecosystems increasing, there is no doubt that the era of ecosystem is here. The EY Ecosystem study shows that companies evidencing leading practice in their mastery of ecosystem outperform those who do not, leading to transformational growth.