Person walking on a wooden walkway at sunset
Person walking on a wooden walkway at sunset

What happens to transfer pricing risk when trust starts at the source?

Better AI-enabled TP outcomes require improving inputs rather than bolting technology on to existing outputs.


In brief
  • TP teams face growing pressure from policy change, business transformation and rising demands for defensible tax positions.
  • Organizations are using AI to connect enterprise-wide data, strengthen evidence and improve confidence in TP outcomes.
  • Trusted inputs and connected processes help create more defensible positions and greater tax certainty.

The success of the transfer pricing (TP) function depends on understanding the company's commercial, supply chain and intellectual property structures, and applying that knowledge to support the business and develop sustainable TP positions. That task has become more challenging as regulatory scrutiny increases, business models evolve, supply chains transform and the volume of business information relevant to TP continues to grow.

These demands place growing pressure on TP teams. Many organizations still rely on fragmented data sources and spreadsheet-driven processes that make it difficult to document business facts as decisions occur, creating challenges for functions that are also adapting to emerging AI capabilities.

The EY 2026 International Tax and Transfer Pricing Survey reveals an expectation gap inside the tax function that must be closed: leaders responsible for setting tax strategy appear to have higher expectations for AI adoption and return on technology investment than many of the practitioners responsible for executing TP on a day-to-day basis.

Vice presidents (VPs) of tax are more than twice as likely as TP leaders to report that TP functions are deploying AI at scale (25% vs. 11%), while TP leaders are twice as likely to report no AI use at all (19% vs. 9%).

VPs of tax are more concerned about the quality of AI-sourced data, while TP leaders are focused on managing risk related to backend exposure of sensitive data. Moreover, those VPs are more likely to expect increases in operational TP budgets, and they are also more likely to name limited technology budgets as their top AI risk.

“Many TP teams are still using technology to improve existing processes, while leadership expects technology to create different outcomes through better data, better inputs and more connected ways of working,” says EY Global Transfer Pricing Leader Tracee Fultz.

Tax risk management

Managing tax risk has long been the top policy driver for TP functions. TP leaders want positions they can defend, numbers they can reproduce and outcomes that hold up years later. Businesses are now on the cusp of confidently gathering and connecting evidence from across the enterprise to support defensible positions, resolve disputes timely and ideally avoid them in the first place. This is a mission that can be accelerated with AI.

Many TP teams are still using technology to improve existing processes, while leadership expects technology to create different outcomes through better data, better inputs and more connected ways of working.

AI’s greatest value lies less in automation and more in its ability to connect enterprise data, improve traceability and strengthen decision-making. In the past six months alone, technology capabilities have advanced significantly, making it increasingly possible to trace comparable financial information to its source and support more reliable, near-real-time intercompany forecasting.

Relying on manual processes
67%
67%
still use spreadsheets and other manual processes for operational TP.

Many TP functions are trying to use AI to do the same work faster or improve existing deliverables by bolting on tools to existing processes. Leaders are also bumping up against familiar challenges: data quality and accessibility. Instead, TP functions could focus on redesigning how data is sourced and captured, improving inputs upstream, creating more trusted information, and generating different outcomes, not just faster outputs. It’s likely that instantly accessible, comparable financial information that’s traceable to its source will become available within a year.

“Having trusted and transparent comparable data available in real time will allow transfer pricing teams to move away from an uncertain annual assessment of whether intercompany transactions are supportable to a confident contemporaneous assessment of what is supportable,” says Jean-Paul Donga, an associate partner in EY Transfer Pricing for Ernst & Young, Australia.

Man standing on rocks
1

Chapter 1

TP functions are under pressure

Pressing concerns and transformation demands complicate daily duties.

Nearly a decade of heightened geopolitical disruption has redrawn supply chains and business models, driving teams to keep pace with constant change in where and how value is created. Every year brings more change to the TP legislative environment, including landmark court cases, more transparency in the form of public country-by-country reporting (CbCR) and new TP rules in multiple jurisdictions.

“We are in one of the most demanding operating environments in decades,” says Craig Hillier, EY Global International Tax and Transactions Leader. “Business leaders expect more from their TP professionals than ever because every move they make has a transfer pricing implication that may create risk down the road.”

 

Almost every organization has felt it: 85% say they expect keeping pace with policy change to be difficult, including 34% who say it will be very difficult. Another 97% report significant supply chain transformation in the form of changing trading partners, patterns and dispersion of value-adding functions, triggering a need to monitor these trends for both risk management and planning opportunities across all tax functions (direct and indirect).

Businesses keep reshaping themselves, and every change carries a TP consequence that someone must later explain and defend. Yet just 37% describe their TP teams as highly engaged or fully embedded with operational teams, which shows how much opportunity exists for TP teams to rely on technology to better connect across the enterprise.

The tax enforcement climate is also more complex and challenging: 47% expect tougher enforcement to shape their policy over the next three years. AI adds another dimension here too. Half of respondents this year cited it as a driver of TP policy, up from 33% in 2024. Tax authorities remain under pressure to raise revenue even though Pillar Two global minimum taxes have been adopted in dozens of jurisdictions. Governments are investing in analytics, and risk assessment technologies and transparency obligations keep expanding. At the same time, audits are running longer and carrying more risk of double taxation.

Because the TP function plays a central role in global organizations, it is highly dependent on enterprise-wide knowledge. The survey reveals a disconnect between technology ambitions and current reality: 67% of respondents still use spreadsheets and other manual processes for operational transfer pricing, up from just 17% in 2024. Half of respondents identify AI as a significant driver of TP change over the next three years, yet adoption remains in its early stages. For instance, 42% are still experimenting with smaller use cases.

Business leaders expect more from their TP professionals than ever because every move they make has a transfer pricing implication that may create risk down the road.

“These results illustrate the underlying challenges of unlocking the real value of these technologies,” says Katherine Pinzon, EY Americas Transfer Pricing Leader. “They require a workforce to adopt a new approach rooted in a connected TP ecosystem, one that redefines inputs by linking the evidence, functions and decisions now scattered across the enterprise.”

Side view of mid adult man carrying backpack jumping over rocky riverbed, Moraine lake, Banff National Park, Alberta Canada
2

Chapter 2

Scattered discipline and the risk management problem

By nature, TP inputs are in every corner of the enterprise.

For TP teams, inputs from business decisions, whether redesigning a supply chain or making commercial or financial changes, arrive at different times from different functions, systems and jurisdictions. Business leaders decide where functions sit, who bears and controls risk, and how products move through the supply chain. Controllers and finance teams record transactions and run intercompany execution. Tax teams track rule changes, interpret the facts and put policy into practice. Controversy professionals often work with the business and TP teams years later to defend the results. Together, these decisions determine a TP outcome that the company must ultimately explain and defend.

Risk management depends on how well organizations identify, capture and connect business facts. The volume of this data is expected to explode in the next five years, an urgent reason why TP functions must redefine their inputs. When critical information stays scattered, teams spend their time rebuilding past events on the backend instead of assessing what those events mean. And without real process change, teams will lack the resources to handle the deluge of information available to them.

Intangibles show the risk most clearly. The survey finds that 37% rate intellectual property (IP) royalties and licensing fees as a high TP risk, with the OECD’s Development, Enhancement, Maintenance, Protection and Exploitation (DEMPE) framework analysis and control of risk close behind at 36%. Another 41% identify core technology as the primary driver of IP value, a source of value that sits deep within the business.

“Intangible value is crucial to attribute the profit to where the value is created and also a high-risk area that requires the most robust cross-organizational analysis and accurate delineation of functional activities to defend it,” says Travis Qiu, EY Greater China TP Leader.

Services show how quickly the challenge turns practical. The policy may be simple, yet supporting it often requires evidence from many business activities, systems and stakeholders.

Scattered inputs also affect TP’s advisory role. Thirty-four percent of respondents say the business consults its TP team regularly, but typically after it has settled key decisions. Another 30% say TP gets involved only on an ad hoc basis or not at all. Aligning tax, finance and business stakeholders ranks as the second-biggest operational challenge. Some 22% rank it first, and 60% place it in their top three. The health sector had the lowest proportion of highly engaged plus fully embedded TP functions at 24% while private equity boasted the most, at 50%.

High risk
37%
37%
rate IP royalties and licensing fees as a high source of risk.

Earlier involvement helps, especially with technology. A TP team that joins a decision as it’s made can identify the information it will need, understand the facts as the business establishes them and record the reasoning while it is fresh. A team that joins late must work backward to document what happened and is often left pulling together disparate organizational data. Where TP meets the monthly close, intercompany execution and operational TP teams spend significant time and money on recurring issues. For example, 36% still rank data quality and availability as their single biggest operational challenge.

When tax controversy is the outcome

Tax controversy is where these scattered inputs come together, and it increasingly plays out in public, adding reputational risk to financial risk. Controversy teams inherit scattered facts under public scrutiny and bear the weight of the disconnection. The survey finds that 63% cite data collection or narrative development as the most burdensome part of meeting public CbCR obligations.

“Public CbCR is both a filing exercise and a data and narrative exercise,” says Oana Popescu, Director, International Tax and Transaction Services, Ernst & Young AG (EY Switzerland). The most demanding elements tend to be assembling the underlying data and developing the narrative explanation, along with the differing interpretations across the EU, she says. “Groups that prepare a consistent set of facts and a clear narrative ahead of publication tend to stand in a better position if tax authorities later refer to those figures in a controversy.”

The share of respondents naming reputation and transparency as very important rose to 54% from 44% in 2024, and strategic alignment rose to 50% from 37%. Effective tax rate management slipped to 51% from 60%. These shifts push companies to explain the business reasoning behind their positions as well as their technical compliance.

When connection breaks down

Manual processes and inconsistent methodologies prevent organizational functions from working from the same evidentiary foundation. More than half of respondents, 53%, say obtaining TP data is difficult, while a further 20% say it is very difficult. Only 28% use dedicated operational TP software, and 45% lean on enterprise resource planning (ERP) systems with operational TP functionalities. As information passes through manual entries, spreadsheets, interviews and separate systems, facts can lose their context or origin. Teams then spend resources validating information rather than assessing what it means.

In the current TP ecosystem, mining the business for qualitative information and monitoring business changes is a significant responsibility, with that information often dispersed among business leaders. The fact-finding process places significant demands on senior executives’ time as teams gather, reconcile and validate information to ensure alignment. This makes it harder to understand performance in real time, explain outcomes consistently and respond quickly when questions arise. The result is a TP process concentrated at the final stages of a business decision and focused on outputs, such as documentation packages, year-end reconciliations and TP policies.

Accessing TP data
73%
73%
say obtaining TP data is difficult or very difficult.

For many organizations, the first hurdle is simply accessing the information they need.

"The information exists somewhere in almost every organization," says Robbert Kaufman, EY Global Operational Transfer Pricing Leader. "The difference between a position you can defend and one you cannot is whether the team can access the information and show it correctly operationalized and reflected in the respective TP policies."

The Bald Head Walking trail in Albany, Western Australia
3

Chapter 3

Managing risk through stronger evidence

Provable positions are the key.

Risk management geared toward effective dispute resolution sits at the heart of TP leaders' priorities. Avoiding lengthy disputes, penalties and litigation is the highest-rated factor shaping TP strategy, with 58% calling it very important. The stakes have only risen with global tax reform: 50% identify double taxation in a Pillar One or Pillar Two environment as a high risk.

During an audit, tax authorities must be able to connect a TP conclusion to the underlying business activity. Companies that can trace figures to their source, validate inputs and explain how the pieces fit together give authorities something they can test rather than simply accept. The discussion can then focus on the economics of the arrangement rather than the credibility of the underlying information.

An enduring quest for better risk management
58%
58%
say tax risk management is a very important factor shaping their TP strategy.

“Good evidence doesn't end the conversation,” says Sandra Knaepen, EY Global TP Controversy Desk Leader and former co-head of the OECD Tax Certainty Unit. “It earns you a better one.”

Dispute management

The same capabilities that help companies defend positions can also help them avoid disputes altogether. Interest in proactive certainty mechanisms continues to rise. “Very useful” ratings for bilateral advanced pricing arrangements (APAs) have roughly doubled in EY International Tax and TP surveys since 2021, while support for mutual agreement procedures (MAPs) increased from 46% to 55% in the last two years alone.

Growing interest in APAs and MAPs reflects a broader shift in how organizations approach controversy. Rather than waiting for disagreements to emerge during audits, many are seeking earlier alignment with tax authorities, greater predictability and reduced exposure to double taxation in an increasingly complex global tax environment.

These tools place a high premium on connected information. An APA, for example, requires organizations to assemble and substantiate their position before a return is filed. Companies that struggle to access data, reconcile information across functions or demonstrate how conclusions were reached often find the process difficult to sustain.

“A major advantage of APAs in the current environment is that it allows taxpayers to engage in real time — using the information and technology available today,” says Joel Cooper, EY Global International Tax and Transactions Services Controversy Leader. “This helps manage the impact of temporal information asymmetry that is enhanced by current rapid advancements in technology.”

Man standing on a suspension bridge surrounded by scenic mountain landscapes
4

Chapter 4

Rethinking inputs and processes for trusted outputs and better outcomes

Reaching evidence at scale means rebuilding what feeds TP and how it runs.

Organizations need access to the right inputs at the right time and processes capable of carrying that information through the TP lifecycle. Progress comes when TP design, operation, documentation and defense draw from the same evidentiary foundation.

The difference today is the ability to access and connect underlying facts at scale. For years, teams built positions from a limited set of interviews, transactions and manually selected comparables because that was all they could realistically gather and reconcile. Because relevant evidence resides across ERP systems, contracts, emails and operational records, technology now makes it easier to trace comparable data back to its source.

Rather than assembling support after the fact, organizations can monitor positions as business conditions evolve, identify events that affect outcomes and capture the reasoning behind decisions when they occur.

“Design informs operation, operation feeds documentation, and documentation — ideally grounded in one consistent data lake — strengthens defense,” says Volker Trautmann, EY Global Transfer Pricing Documentation CoE Co-leader.

When teams redesign their processes to capture facts as decisions occur, they can reduce the reconciliation and reconstruction that consume so much year-end effort. By the time a tax authority requests information, much of the supporting narrative already exists. In that sense, the organizations making the most progress no longer treat audit readiness as a separate exercise but build it into the TP lifecycle itself.

AI and standard data earn their place

Tax leaders see the potential of AI clearly. As noted previously, half of respondents expect advancements in AI to have a significant impact on TP over the next three years, ranking it ahead of every regulatory and commercial pressure they face. Yet the same survey shows how early the shift still is. Only 17% deploy agents or machine learning to any meaningful degree, and among those deploying AI, 11% use it extensively in audit preparation.

That distance between expectation and practice is a challenge that many companies face today. AI delivers on its promise only when the inputs and processes beneath it are ready.

“Using agentic workflows with AI-ready data is transformative,” says Rebecca Coke, EY Global Transfer Pricing Product Portfolio Leader. “Using AI with unstructured data of unknown provenance and context often leads to high token costs and very wrong answers.”

On the inputs, AI pulls a fact from one system, a decision from another and a comparable from a third, and holds them together or flags when data is not connected. Both inputs and process depend entirely on data quality and accessibility — which is precisely the main obstacle cited by 38% of survey respondents, making it their biggest AI readiness risk.

This is why the work starts with reframing and reevaluating the inputs and data, not the technology. A company that learns to mine data across the enterprise builds a reliable base of connected evidence and creates one source of truth, where each trusted input can compound and make the next connection possible. That is the first sign of an environment where the enterprise’s TP evidence works as a whole rather than in pieces and where trusted sources are built.

Using agentic workflows with AI-ready data is transformative. Using AI with unstructured data of unknown provenance and context often leads to high token costs and very wrong answers.

With two-thirds expecting operational TP budgets to rise over the next three years, the question is where that investment goes. The most effective investments strengthen the inputs that feed the TP lifecycle. Organizations that capture and connect business facts earlier can produce stronger outputs, from DEMPE analyses and year-end close activities to documentation and controversy support.

Tools layered onto disconnected information may accelerate existing processes, but they cannot resolve underlying data challenges. Investments that improve data quality, traceability and connectivity strengthen every capability built on top of them.

Mediterranean sea and coastline
5

Chapter 5

The connected TP ecosystem

Better risk management follows when information, functions and decisions work as one.

The components of a more integrated ecosystem already exist: design, operational TP, intercompany execution, documentation, controversy and advisory. AI helps carry information across the lifecycle, while tax professionals contribute the judgment and experience needed to interpret and act on it.

An ecosystem works because knowledge, once captured, becomes available to everyone who needs it. Every position a TP team takes rests on a body of reasoning, and in some cases, that reasoning still lives in one analyst’s files or one adviser’s memory, and it leaves with them.

When a team documents why it characterized a transaction in a certain way, or how it built a cost base, that reasoning becomes part of a record the whole function can draw on. A question answered once doesn't have to be answered again from scratch. A methodology agreed in one jurisdiction informs the approach in the next. And a position taken years ago can be reproduced on demand.

Tax leaders want what they have always wanted: certainty they can stand behind, positions they can reproduce and outcomes that hold up years later. Now, evidence-based certainty is finally within reach. To empower a connected TP ecosystem, focus on the following steps:

Build the foundation before the tools. Leaders are investing in cleaning and organizing data they can trust, trace and connect, so everything built stands on a solid foundation.

Advance inputs and processes together. Transformation requires reconsidering both the information feeding TP decisions and the processes built around those inputs.

Capture knowledge as the work happens. Organizations that record why a decision was made, while it is being made, stop relearning what they already knew and can defend today's outcomes with yesterday's logic intact.

Connect the discipline without redrawing it. Humans are ultimately in charge of managing shared information, linking design, operation, documentation and defense so they draw on the same facts and make informed judgments.

TP functions that connect the evidence they already hold will help shape the future of their enterprise. They will build an ecosystem where information, judgment and processes work as one, turning risk management and a quest for certainty from an aspiration into a capability.

AI can increase productivity, but productivity alone isn't the end goal. The greater opportunity is to create trust: trust in the data, trust in the decisions built on it and trust that those decisions can still be explained years later. For TP leaders, that may prove to be the most valuable outcome of all.

Summary

Transfer pricing leaders face mounting pressure from regulatory change, supply chain transformation and growing demands for defensible tax positions. Yet many organizations still rely on fragmented data, manual processes and disconnected sources of business information. The EY 2026 International Tax and Transfer Pricing Survey finds that the greatest opportunity for AI lies not in automating existing work, but in improving how transfer pricing functions capture, connect and use data across the enterprise. Organizations that strengthen inputs, improve traceability and build evidence as decisions occur can create more trusted outcomes, better manage risk and move closer to evidence-based certainty.

Related articles

How tax authorities use digital tools to reshape controversy

Digital tax administration is changing the point at which tax controversy begins and how organizations prepare for it.

Why managing tax compliance and tax controversy should be co-sourced

Businesses spend equal amounts on tax compliance and managing controversy. Changing the way they operate could fix that.

What fragmented global tax cooperation means for business

Global tax cooperation is fragmented across forums and more connected with trade and geopolitics, changing how businesses need to prepare. Learn more.

About this article