Will local ambition fast-track or frustrate the global energy transition?

Authors
Ben Warren

Partner, Renewables Corporate Finance, Ernst & Young LLP

Adviser on procurement, regulatory policy and mergers and acquisitions across the entire energy, waste and water value chains.

Arnaud de Giovanni

EY Global Power & Utilities Strategy and Transactions Leader

Future-focused thinker with over two decades of experience guiding power and utilities businesses through transformation.

17 minute read 13 Jun 2023

Show resources

  • RECAI 61 report – June 2023

  • RECAI 61 Top 40 ranking – June 2023

  • RECAI 61 PPA Index – June 2023

    Download 202 KB
  • RECAI 61 Normalized index ranking – June 2023

RECAI 61: The Inflation Reduction Act has sparked a renewables race, but may skew international capital allocation and shift net-zero goals.

This article is a summary of the 61st edition of the Renewable Energy Country Attractiveness Index (RECAI).

Download the full report.

In brief
  • Governments are eyeing domestically produced, low-cost, low-carbon energy in a bid to reduce their dependence on imports.
  • The US Inflation Reduction Act has accelerated investment into clean energy, but risks causing an imbalance in international capital allocation.
  • Localized supply chains will have to be rapidly built or strengthened to meet net-zero targets.

The global renewables industry is set to take a gigantic leap forward, as the push for energy security and a recessionary environment combine to create an ideal investment climate.

Geopolitical events, and subsequent actions taken by governments, have made markets increasingly aware of the issues posed by reliance on imported energy, global competition for gas supply, and legacy pricing links between natural gas and renewables. As a result, developing policies to encourage the buildout of — and investment into — renewables has risen rapidly up government agendas.

Markets around the world are passing laws to boost domestic renewables generation and enhance energy security, with the US Inflation Reduction Act the most significant legislation to date. It offers various incentives, credits and grants for the development and commercialization of green technologies and has sparked a race to the top among international markets eager to boost the competitiveness of their renewables sectors. Major economies, including the European Union, China and India, have stepped up investment and raised renewables targets in response.

This increased competition should speed up development of nascent green technologies and accelerate the energy transition. But there is concern some markets could be left further behind. While domestic renewable energy could accelerate markets’ broader economies, the increased pressure on supply chains will require new partnerships to be developed — and quickly.

Despite these reservations, increased policy support for renewables is creating a unique opportunity for the industry, worldwide, to stimulate demand and accelerate the drive for global decarbonization. 

Read in RECAI 61:

  1. Analysis: The impact of market actions on global net-zero aims
  2. Key developments: renewables highlights from around the world
  3. Normalized index: showcasing markets performing above expectations for their economic size
  4. Corporate PPAs ride out bumpy year to come out on top in Europe
  5. Regional focus: India
(Chapter breaker)
1

Chapter 1

Analysis: The impact of market actions on global net-zero aims

Policy support for domestically produced renewables comes with challenges, as well as opportunities.

Domestically produced, low-cost, low-carbon and, in some cases, low-lead time energy – using local technology – looks more attractive than ever for governments around the world, with renewables being placed at the center of their energy policies.

The US Inflation Reduction Act (the Act), for example, prioritizes energy security and climate change through a combined investment of US$369b.1 A broad range of renewables assets is set to benefit from the Act’s incentives, credits and grants; this includes wind, solar, energy storage, carbon capture utilization and storage, the production of clean hydrogen, renewable natural gas, nuclear and electric vehicles. In the first eight months since its passage in August 2022, more than US$150b of capital investment poured into utility-scale US clean energy.2

Foreign companies are among those that have announced new US clean energy investments, and there is concern that the Act could cause an imbalance in international capital allocation. Other key markets, therefore, have had to respond rapidly to the potential impact of the legislation.

A prime example is the European Commission’s relaxation of state-aid rules3 to simplify subsidies for batteries, solar panels, wind turbines, heat pumps, electrolyzers, and carbon capture technology, as well as for the production of the components and raw materials used to manufacture them.4 The European Union’s REPowerEU initiative was already looking to bolster the bloc’s energy security by replacing natural gas imports from Russia with renewables, hydrogen, and biomethane.5 The UK is also planning energy reforms to delink gas and electricity prices.6

To spur investment in decarbonization, market competition is needed to speed up technological advances and bring cost down. Doing so will benefit the global energy transition.

India is expanding its renewables industry through a combination of ambitious government targets and private-sector actions; and China is stepping up activity in its dominant domestic market, while targeting exports where it already holds a competitive advantage, such as solar components. Other Asian markets, including Malaysia and Indonesia, are looking at how their solar markets can still flourish in the face of increased competition from larger economies.

Such competition can help speed up technological advances and bring down costs, which should benefit the energy transition and spur the investment needed to decarbonize and keep global temperature rises in check.

Markets leaning on renewables to help push their economies out of recession could also benefit from the need to strengthen domestic supply chains; creating jobs, expanding various industries, increasing gross domestic product, as well as enhancing people’s welfare.7

However, localized supply chains will have to be rapidly built or strengthened if net-zero targets are not to be delayed. Building these out will require new structures and partnerships to be created, and this will take time – especially as the International Monetary Fund expects economic growth to fall in 2023 and only rebound slightly in 2024.8

Despite such a slow-growth outlook, the investment landscape for low-carbon technologies has continued to evolve in recent years, as economies recover from the impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic while setting increasingly ambitious decarbonization targets. After an initial steady double-digit growth, energy transition deal volumes exploded over the last two years, with more growth expected as capital continues to flow into the space. In North America, deal volumes across all investor segments remained strong in 2022 following 2021's record year, though with a modest reduction in overall volumes.9

Conditions, therefore, appear ripe for turbocharging renewable energy demand and accelerating the journey to net zero – but it remains to be seen whether market interventions such as the US Inflation Reduction Act will speed up or delay the energy transition.

Will local ambition fast-track or frustrate the global energy transition?

Download the RECAI 61 report (pdf)      Subscribe to RECAI updates

(Chapter breaker)
2

Chapter 2

Key developments: renewables highlights from around the world

Key developments: From Egypt’s wind ambitions to Japan’s push to increase solar PV market share.

Developing policies to encourage the buildout of renewables has risen to the top of many governments’ agendas, and this push for energy security in a recessionary environment has created a viable opportunity for significant investment.

  • Image description

    The above interactive graphic includes two separate charts. The first one showing the RECAI top 10 movement in ranking and the second one showing movement in index scores from edition 55, May 2022 to edition 61, June 2023.

Download the RECAI top 40 ranking (pdf) for details on technology-specific scores, and see methodology for details on how ranking and scores are determined.

  • Image description

    The above interactive graphic highlights the most significant developments within 10 of the world’s top 40 markets showing their RECAI ranking and movement compared with the previous RECAI.

(Chapter breaker)
3

Chapter 3

Normalized index

Showcasing markets performing above expectations for their economic size.

The RECAI uses various criteria to compare the attractiveness of renewables markets, such as the magnitude of development pipeline, that reflect the absolute size of the renewable investment opportunity. Hence, the index naturally benefits large economies. By normalizing with the gross domestic product, we can see which markets are performing above expectations for their economic size. In this way, the normalized index helps reveal ambitious plans in smaller economies, creating some attractive alternatives for potential investors.

Image of power purchase agreement top 40 ranking compared with the previous PPA ranking.
  • Image description

    The above graphic shows the normalized RECAI Top 10 ranking compared with the RECAI ranking. 

Discover more

To explore the top 40 normalized ranking and other RECAI insights

Download the report

(Chapter breaker)
4

Chapter 4

Corporate PPAs ride out bumpy year to come out on top in Europe

As global markets calm, prices have eased and the PPA market is becoming more balanced again.

During 2022, corporate power purchase agreements (PPAs) significantly overtook utility PPAs in Europe, both in terms of capacity (7GW of 8.4GW) and deal count (129 of 161 deals).10 This trend is expected to develop in other parts of the world.

It has not been an easy ride for corporates in the past year however, with volatile, sky-high pricing – plus project scarcity – flipping the market in the sellers’ favor. Inflation also affected PPA pricing structures, with few developers agreeing to no indexation – but this requirement has eased, with most now offering flat nominal pricing.

During early 2023 as global markets calmed, prices have eased considerably, and the PPA market is becoming more balanced again. With wholesale power price futures generally reducing compared with current prices in many markets, some countries being at risk of increased cannibalization of renewables’ capture prices, and developers needing long-term revenue security, the power of a long-term PPA is sending sellers back to corporates.

Physical and sleeved PPAs are becoming less popular, as “shaping” costs have spiraled, while pay-as-produced virtual PPAs are now the norm in many deregulated markets.

Image of power purchase agreement top 40 ranking compared with the previous PPA ranking.
  • Image description

    The above graphic shows the corporate power purchase agreement top 40 ranking compared with the previous PPA ranking.

The EY corporate PPA Index uses key parameters from four pillars to analyze and rank the growth potential of a nation’s corporate PPA market. For details on data and methodology, download the EY Corporate PPA Index (pdf)

(Chapter breaker)
5

Chapter 5

Regional focus: India

Round-the-clock electricity supply is a must if the market is to be a key producer of green hydrogen.

India is experiencing rapid growth in its renewables industry. According to the International Energy Agency, it has the fastest rate of renewable electricity growth of any major economy, with new capacity additions on track to double between the start of 2022 and 2026,11 having already doubled between 2015 and 2022 to reach 163GW.12

As of February 2023, renewables accounted for about 42.5% of India’s installed power-generation capacity.13 Solar has been the market’s most important renewables asset, accounting for 63GW of its total renewables’ capacity, followed by hydropower at 47GW and wind power at 42GW.14

The government’s latest draft National Electricity Plan sets out how it intends to expand the transmission infrastructure network by 300GW by 2030, and reach 500GW of renewables capacity by 2030,15 while achieving net-zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2070.

Meanwhile, India’s private sector – and, in particular, commercial and industrial (C&I) companies – is increasingly looking to renewable PPAs because of the high grid tariffs associated with coal-derived energy.16 With the capital market evolving around C&I PPAs, costs for power have come down compared with purchasing from the grid. Indeed, India is now one of the fastest-growing PPA markets in the world.

India's export advantage could be boosted by new and upcoming technologies, such as green hydrogen, which are making their way into the domestic renewable energy mix. This reinforces the importance of RTC supply of usable clean energy.

The growing share of renewable power generation means that supply intermittency is becoming a bigger concern. As a result, ensuring round-the-clock (RTC) supply is becoming more of a priority. India’s pure pumped storage capacity, likely to increase in the coming years, is expected to assist with this.

In addition, new and upcoming technologies, such as green hydrogen, are making their way into the domestic renewable energy mix to such an extent that they could boost India’s export advantage. This reinforces the importance of RTC supply of usable clean energy for potential offtakers.

Under its recently launched National Green Hydrogen Mission – which has an initial outlay of INR197b (US$2.4b) – India is also targeting production of 5 million metric tonnes of green hydrogen by 2030,17 which could help it become a green hydrogen export hub, shipping to Europe. And India’s Greenko Group has already signed a memorandum of understanding for negotiating a first-of-its-kind deal to supply green ammonia to Germany’s Uniper.18

While India has set ambitious targets for its renewables industry, it will need to provide more subsidies for industry players to achieve its goal of 500GW of renewable capacity by 2030. It is estimated that a doubling of investment – to INR2.44t (US$28b) per year – will be needed between 2022 and 2029.19 Nevertheless, as the market increases its support for renewables, storage and green hydrogen, it is making significant progress on decarbonization and is a fast-growing market on which to keep a close eye.

  • Show article references#Hide article references

    1. “Summary: The Inflation Reduction Act of 2022,” Senate Democrats website, www.democrats.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/inflation_reduction_act_one_page_summary.pdf, accessed 30 March 2023
    2. Clean energy investing in America, American Clean Power, April 2023
    3. “State aid: Commission amends General Block Exemption rules to further facilitate and speed up green and digital transition,” European Commission website, accessed 14 April 2023
    4. “EU relaxes subsidy rules to prevent green tech companies from relocating to the United States,” EuroNews website, accessed 30 March 2023
    5. “REPowerEU – Joint European action for more secure and sustainable energy,” EY website, accessed 30 March 2023
    6. “Reforms outlined for Britain’s capacity market to secure a clean energy future,” Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy, 9 January 2023, via UK Government website
    7. Renewable energy benefits: measuring the economics, IRENA, 2016
    8.  “A rocky recovery,” International Monetary Fund website, www.imf.org/en/Publications/WEO/Issues/2023/04/11/world-economic-outlook-april-2023, accessed 14 April 2023.
    9. EY-Parthenon analysis
    10. European PPA Market Outlook 2023, Pexapark 2023
    11. “India’s clean energy transition is rapidly under way, benefiting the entire world,” International Energy Agency (IEA) website
    12. Renewable Capacity Statistics 2023, International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA), 2023
    13. “Renewable energy,” Invest India website, www.investindia.gov.in/sector/renewable-energy, accessed 21 April 2023.
    14. Renewable Capacity Statistics 2023, IRENA, 2023
    15. “India’s journey to 500GW: reaching the capacity and investment targets,” IEA website, accessed 21 April 2023
    16. “The continued rise of renewable corporate PPAs in India,” Mondaq website, accessed 25 April 2023
    17. National green hydrogen mission, Government of India, Ministry of New and Renewable Energy, January 2023
    18. “Uniper and Greenko signed exclusivity for greem ammonia offtake to EU from India’s first green ammonia project in Kakinada,” Uniper and Greenko, 7 February 2023, via Greenko website
    19. “Year-end Review 2022,” Ministry of Power, 27 December 2022, on Government of India website

     

Summary

To address concerns about energy supply and affordability, governments are legislating to accelerate domestic renewables production, using local technology. The US Inflation Reduction Act, for example, has sparked competition in the industry, which could help accelerate decarbonization. However, it could also cause an imbalance in international capital allocation, and net-zero targets could be missed if localized supply chains are not put in place quickly enough.

About this article

Authors
Ben Warren

Partner, Renewables Corporate Finance, Ernst & Young LLP

Adviser on procurement, regulatory policy and mergers and acquisitions across the entire energy, waste and water value chains.

Arnaud de Giovanni

EY Global Power & Utilities Strategy and Transactions Leader

Future-focused thinker with over two decades of experience guiding power and utilities businesses through transformation.