In brief
Consumer data is the engine for companies today, enabling their business strategies, stronger relationships and greater innovation. Yet, in an ever-evolving landscape of privacy regulations globally, noncompliance risks and penalties are a constant concern. Another twist occurred in July 2020, when the EU-US Privacy Shield was invalidated, complicating business as usual for companies that depend on standard contractual clauses (SCCs) to collect and process EU personal data.
Organizations that previously relied on the Privacy Shield must immediately institute an alternative approved transfer mechanism for EU data or risk running afoul of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), with fines of up to 4% of their annual revenue or €20 million, whichever is higher.
Companies with a consumer footprint in the EU must revisit their data strategies: conduct a risk assessment, recognize that removing data has consequences, avoid overbroad collections, minimize eDiscovery, ensure proper notification and deploy strong security measures. Before exploring these action steps in more depth, it’s important to understand the implications behind decisions by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU). An EY report contains more background as well.
The Privacy Shield was designed to help companies comply with the GDPR when transferring personal data from the EU to the US. Max Schrems, an Austrian lawyer, successfully argued that the Safe Harbor — the predecessor of the Privacy Shield — did not sufficiently protect his data when transferred to the US. Then, in a decision by the CJEU that became known as Schrems II, the Privacy Shield was also found to be inadequate.
The CJEU upheld the validity of SCCs as an approved transfer mechanism. Yet it will require, prior to any transfer, stricter scrutiny and a case-by-case assessment by the exporting and importing parties, as to whether the laws of the importing country provide an adequate level of protection essentially equivalent to that guaranteed within the EU by the GDPR. If the parties determine that the SCC cannot be complied with due to the local laws, the CJEU instructs the data exporters to immediately cease all data transfers and/or to terminate the SCC.
eDiscovery practitioners can cautiously use SCCs but might have to implement supplementary measures to comply with the GDPR and other strategies. That may include using the derogations under the GDPR Article 49 based, for example, on consent of the data subject or on the performance of a contract to transfer personal data out of the EU to the US.
Schrems II emphasizes that the SCCs must also address guarantees that prevent access to the data by public authorities or surveillance services. It is particularly important for companies relying on SCCs for eDiscovery to revisit them following the CJEU’s decision and confirm GDPR compliance.
To meet the new requirements:
Taking these measures offers benefits beyond the present day — they can also position organizations to potentially evolve more easily to address other regulatory issues developing elsewhere in the world.
In the aftermath of Schrems II, companies seeking eDiscovery in Europe should keep in mind that the validity of standard contractual clauses (SCCs) for transferring data from EU to the US depends on whether these SCCs include effective mechanisms that confirm compliance with the level of protection essentially equivalent to that guaranteed by the GDPR.
Related Articles
How to comply with data subject access requests
The pandemic and shift to a remote workforce make a clear compliance strategy and workflows for fulfilling DSARs more important than ever. Read more.