EY black logo

EY Tax News Update: Edition 10, 2024

EY Tax News Update: Edition 10, 2024

Welcome to the final edition of EY’s tax news for 2024. This edition covers key tax developments for November. You can also find details of upcoming EY Global webcasts, along with links to EY insights.

We will be back next year to keep you updated on what has been happening in the tax world. In the meantime, we wish you a safe and happy holiday season.

In brief

Inland Revenue updates

  • Current draft consultation items:
    • Income tax treatment of gift cards and products provided as trade rebates or promotions
    • Information sharing with the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment
    • Implications of a residential property moving between the standard tax rules and mixed-use asset rules
  • New finalised guidance, including:
    • Interpretation Statement on overdrawn shareholder loan account balances
    • Technical Decision Summaries on: permanent establishment; accommodation provided to an employee; transitional residency and cryptoassets
  • Software development expenses – withdrawal of 1993 Policy Statement
  • Information collection framework
  • Long-term insights briefing – scope of topic confirmed
  • Other updates

Government and political updates

  • Refreshed Tax and Social Policy Work Programme indicates what is on the horizon
  • Bill on FBT and zero emissions vehicles is not progressing
  • Initial Digital Platform Information reporting deadline approaching
  • Agriculture removed from New Zealand’s Emissions Trading Scheme
  • Economic update

International updates

  • Australia: key tax bills pass Parliament; embedded royalties case being appealed
  • United Kingdom – Autumn Budget
  • United States – potential impact of election outcome on global trade

EY Global Webcasts

  • EY talks tax | The future of AI in tax: insights and practical implications for the tax function (podcast)

EY Insights

  • Tax Guides – various tax matters covering over 150 jurisdictions
  • Six actions for tax teams before year-end 2024
  • How will GenAI shape tax and finance transformation?
  • Six steps to prepare for the operational impact of Pillar Two
  • Italy proposes significant changes to the Digital Services Tax
  • G20 Leaders stress importance of progressive taxation and reiterate their commitment to BEPS 2.0
  • UK Government responds to consultation on introducing UK CBAM
  • The Latest on BEPS and Beyond | November 2024

                Inland Revenue updates


Current draft consultation items

Consultation item type

Description

Public consultation closes

Draft Question We’ve Been Asked PUB00462: What is the income tax treatment of gift cards and products provided as trade rebates or promotions?

Explains the income tax treatment of gift cards and products provided by trade suppliers to trade customers (business to business) as trade rebates, promotions, or rewards for trade customers buying goods or services from trade suppliers. Also includes discussion of the situation where the gift cards or products are passed onto employees.

18 December

Discussion document: Information sharing between Inland Revenue and the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment

The Government is seeking feedback on a proposed information sharing agreement between Inland Revenue and the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment (MBIE). The agreement would allow Inland Revenue and MBIE to share prescribed information with each other for the benefits outlined in the discussion document.

13 December

Draft Interpretation Statement PUB00482: Income tax – implications of a residential property moving between the standard tax rules and the mixed-use asset rules

Considers situations where a person’s use of their residential property has changed so the property moves between the standard tax rules and mixed-use asset rules. Accompanied by two related draft fact sheets.

13 December


New finalised guidance

Inland Revenue guidance items finalised since our last update include:

Finalised guidance name

Description

Interpretation Statement IS 24/09: Income tax – Overdrawn shareholder loan account balances

Considers common tax issues associated with overdrawn shareholder loan accounts held in New Zealand resident close companies. Accompanied by a fact sheet.

Technical Decision Summary TDS 24/20: Permanent establishment

Summarises a decision of the Tax Counsel Office in relation to a private ruling involving the provision of services by a New Zealand company to an overseas company. Includes consideration of whether the overseas company had a permanent establishment in New Zealand.

Technical Decision Summary TDS 24/21: Accommodation provided to an employee

Summarises a decision of the Tax Counsel Office in relation to a dispute regarding whether accommodation was provided to an employee, and the value of the accommodation for income tax and GST purposes.

Technical Decision Summary TDS 24/22: Transitional residency and cryptoassets

Summarises a decision of the Tax Counsel Office in relation to a private ruling involving a natural person. The main issues were whether the taxpayer would qualify as a transitional resident, and whether amounts derived from the sale of cryptoassets through overseas exchanges have a source in New Zealand.


Software development expenses – withdrawal of 1993 Policy Statement

Inland Revenue has withdrawn the remaining parts of the Commissioner’s 1993 Policy Statement on computer software published in an Appendix to Tax Information Bulletin Vol 4, No 10 (May 1993). This means the Appendix does not represent the Commissioner’s view of the income tax treatment of software development expenditure. The withdrawal notice is available on Inland Revenue’s website here.

Clarifying the income tax treatment of software development expenditure is part of the Government’s refreshed Tax and Social Policy Work Programme – we could see more from Inland Revenue’s Policy team on this topic.

Information collection framework

Inland Revenue has published an information collection framework, outlining how they decide whether they should collect customer information. The framework applies to proposals to collect information from or about multiple customers (not for evaluating information requests about a specific customer).

The principles in the framework are intended to help Inland Revenue prepare and review collection proposals by using a consistent approach and broadly include:

  • Authorised by law – collect information only as allowed by law and where it relates to the Commissioner's functions

  • Whole of Inland Revenue approach – where possible, input will be sought from across Inland Revenue to consider the merits of the proposed collection

  • Compliance costs, benefits, and other impacts – the impacts (including compliance costs) of the proposal on affected parties, customers in general and the tax system

  • Explain and consult – explain why the information is required and, where practicable, give external parties an opportunity to comment

  • Support the Crown-Māori relationship – whether the proposal is consistent with Inland Revenue’s role supporting the Crown in its relationships with Māori under the Treaty of Waitangi

  • Strategic direction – whether the proposal supports Inland Revenue's strategic direction

The information collection framework can be viewed in full on Inland Revenue’s website here.

Long-term insights briefing – scope of topic confirmed

As a reminder, Inland Revenue recently sought feedback on the scope of its 2025 long-term insights briefing (LTIB). Inland Revenue, like other government departments, must produce a LTIB once every three years. LTIBs do not reflect current government policy, nor do they seek to identify immediate actions or make recommendations to current ministers. Instead, the aim is to promote public discussion on key policy choices with a longer-term focus.

Inland Revenue has now published a summary of submissions received, along with copies of the submissions, on the scoping consultation document. The scope of the topic has also now been confirmed and remains largely the same as was proposed in the consultation document, with minor refinements made as a result of submissions.

A draft of the LTIB will be released for public consultation in early 2025. For more information, see Inland Revenue’s Tax Policy website here.

Other updates

Other Inland Revenue updates include:

  • Further to a previous edition of EY’s tax news, Inland Revenue has now stopped using custom audience lists due to public concern – see the Inland Revenue media release here. There is also a statement published on the Office of the Privacy Commissioner website in response to Inland Revenue's updated hashing information here.

  • Inland Revenue staff are making unannounced visits to hundreds of businesses who may not be meeting all their tax obligations as employers. These businesses have been identified from the list of nearly 7,000 anonymous tipoffs Inland Revenue receives each year, with the visits forming part of Inland Revenue’s hidden economy suite of work. For more information, refer to the Inland Revenue media release here.

  • A new overview page is available on Inland Revenue’s website here, setting out various existing Inland Revenue guidance items on how GST applies to land.

                Government and political updates

Refreshed Tax and Social Policy Work Programme indicates what is on the horizon

The Government Tax and Social Policy Work Programme (Work Programme) has been updated and is the first Work Programme issued by the coalition Government. It aims to continue the Government’s focus on rebuilding the economy and improving fiscal sustainability.

The refreshed Work Programme contains few surprises, with some of the items already included in the current Taxation (Annual Rates for 2024–25, Emergency Response, and Remedial Measures) Bill. Some key items to note from the Work Programme include:

  • Fringe Benefit Tax (FBT) review – following the conclusions reached in an earlier stewardship review, it is clear that improvements in FBT settings, to both improve overall compliance and reduce compliance and administrative costs, can be made.

  • Reviewing the Foreign Investment Fund tax rules – in accordance with the Minister of Revenue’s previous indication that the Government is looking into aspects of these rules.

  • Exploring compliance cost reductions, including improving tax compliance for small businesses – the Minister of Revenue has previously signalled an interest in reforms to ease compliance costs and improve productivity, and given the size of the SME sector it is unsurprising to see Officials focus their efforts here.

  • Trust disclosures post-implementation review – which we are hopeful will result in simplifications to the disclosures and forms.

  • Reviewing elements of the charities and not-for-profits sector – Officials have been considering options for reform for some time, including a stewardship review of the donations tax credit regime. The Government has also previously indicated that it is keen to review the rules applicable to businesses owned by charities.

  • Simplifying tax compliance for Māori authorities – the scope of any review is uncertain but given the growth in the Māori economy and the extensive compliance costs imposed on the sector, it is not surprising to see the Government keen to seek improvements in the current settings.

  • Clarifying the income tax treatment of software development expenditure – likely necessitated by the current tax rules in this area appearing outdated relative to the modern ways of using and acquiring software.

While it is great to see the release of the Work Programme, necessarily the descriptions given to the items are succinct and the programme is light on detail. We expect many of the projects may be subject to public consultation in the coming year. We would also not be surprised to see additional tax policy reforms included in the 2025 Budget. The downside of using the Budget process is that it does not allow for extensive consultation. The Work Programme itself notes that public consultation plays an important role in creating and sustaining a durable and widely accepted tax system.

The Government’s keen focus on prudent fiscal management is likely to require finely balanced policy reforms. While the Work Programme suggests areas where additional reform will be considered, it remains to be seen what can be delivered in this Parliamentary term.

We understand the Government intends to update the Work Programme periodically to reflect its current priorities. The current Work Programme (and future iterations) can be found on Inland Revenue’s Tax Policy website here. We will wait with anticipation to see what other items are added post-Budget 2025 as we head into the second half of the term.

Bill on FBT and zero emissions vehicles is not progressing

The Income Tax (Clean Transport FBT Exclusion) Amendment Bill failed to pass its First Reading in Parliament and is not progressing further.

As a reminder, this was a Private Member’s Bill (with the MP in charge being Hon Julie Anne Genter of the Green Party) that was drawn from ballot and introduced to Parliament earlier this year. It proposed to remove FBT for five years from zero emissions vehicles provided to staff as part of their salary package. It also suggested a change for double cab utes.

Initial Digital Platform Information reporting deadline approaching

As a reminder, New Zealand has adopted the OECD Model Rules for Reporting by Platform Operators with respect to Sellers in the Sharing and Gig Economy. From 1 January 2024, platform operators based in New Zealand are required to collect information on sellers that receive consideration from relevant services through digital platforms and report annually to Inland Revenue.

Required information on sellers for the year ended 31 December 2024 must be reported to Inland Revenue by 7 February 2025. Refer to the EY Global Tax News Alert here for details.

Agriculture removed from New Zealand’s Emissions Trading Scheme

The Climate Change Response (Emissions Trading Scheme Agricultural Obligations) Amendment Bill, which amends the Climate Change Response Act 2002 to remove agriculture activities from New Zealand’s Emissions Trading Scheme, received Royal assent on 25 November. Instead, it is expected that a new Pastoral Sector Group will address biogenic methane.

Economic update

Treasury has published the Interim Financial Statements of the Government for the three months ended 30 September 2024. Key figures include:

  • Tax revenue of $28.7 billion, which was close to forecast.
  • Operating balance before gains and losses deficit of $4.2 billion ($0.7 billion more than forecast).

Finance Minister Nicola Willis noted the results are weaker than the Budget forecast, reinforcing the need to drive growth and maintain careful spending. Refer to the Treasury media release here and related Beehive release here for more information.

Keep an eye out for the next major fiscal announcement in the Half Year Update and Budget Policy Statement, expected to be published on 17 December.

            International updates

Australia

Key tax bills pass Parliament

A number of tax bills recently passed all stages of Parliament in Australia, including:

  • Legislation to implement Pillar Two of the OECD/G20 Two-Pillar solution – including a 15% global minimum tax and domestic minimum tax. Certain aspects of the rules will apply to fiscal years starting from 1 January 2024, with other aspects applying to fiscal years starting from 1 January 2025. In-scope groups need to prepare for the financial reporting and compliance obligations that will be required as a result of this new law.

  • Australian Public Country by Country Reporting (PCbCR) – Australia's PCbCR regime will be one of the most comprehensive PCbCR regimes globally and additional work will be required by covered groups to comply compared to disclosures for confidential CbCR and under the European Union PCbCR directive. Significant penalties may apply for late lodgement and non-compliance.

  • Changes to the foreign resident capital gains tax regime – increase in the foreign resident capital gains withholding tax rate from 12.5% to 15%, and removal of the threshold before which withholding applies for real property/company title interests.

  • Disclosure of subsidiary tax residency information – clarifying the tax residency disclosures required in the annual financial report by reporting entities in relation to subsidiaries.

For further information on any of these Australian developments, please get in touch with your usual EY tax advisor.

Embedded royalty case being appealed

The Australian High Court has granted the Australian Commissioner of Taxation special leave to appeal against the Full Federal Court decision in PepsiCo, Inc v FCT [2024] FCAFC 86.

As a reminder, the Full Federal Court delivered a landmark decision earlier this year where it overturned the first instance decision of the Federal Court. The Full Court, by majority, found that a royalty did not exist in an agreement between arm's-length parties in circumstances where the agreement did not expressly provide for a royalty. The Full Court also found by majority that Australia’s Diverted Profits Tax provisions did not apply. The outcome of the appeal will be eagerly anticipated by taxpayers.

United Kingdom

The United Kingdom Autumn Budget brought significant tax increases, particularly for employers, while also seeking to plan for the future. Further details are available in the EY Global Tax News Alert here, and on ey.com here (including a link to watch an on-demand webcast).

United States

The outcome of the recent United States election is set to have a significant impact on trade policies, global partnerships, tariff structures and the overall economic landscape, both domestically and abroad.

For information on the potential impact on global trade, refer to the EY Global Tax News Alert here.

                EY Global Webcasts


EY talks tax | The future of AI in tax: insights and practical implications for the tax function – podcast available here.

                EY Insights


Contact us

Dean Madsen | New Zealand Tax Leader
Ernst & Young Limited
New Zealand
Dean.Madsen@nz.ey.com

Paul Dunne | New Zealand Tax Policy Leader
Ernst & Young Limited
New Zealand
Paul.Dunne@nz.ey.com

Aaron Quintal | Partner, Private Client Services
Ernst & Young Limited
New Zealand
Aaron.Quintal@nz.ey.com

Sarah-Jane Leslie | Senior Manager, Tax Policy
Ernst & Young Limited
New Zealand
Sarah-Jane.Leslie@nz.ey.com

Sladjana Lines | Senior Manager, Tax Policy
Ernst & Young Limited
New Zealand
Sladjana.Lines@nz.ey.com