EY helps clients create long-term value for all stakeholders. Enabled by data and technology, our services and solutions provide trust through assurance and help clients transform, grow and operate.
At EY, our purpose is building a better working world. The insights and services we provide help to create long-term value for clients, people and society, and to build trust in the capital markets.
Climate risks, global pressures and shifting expectations are reshaping Canada’s insurance sector in a pivotal moment of change.
In brief
Canadian insurers face sustained volatility from economic uncertainty, climate losses, regulatory change and evolving customer expectations.
Cost discipline, AI adoption and regulatory readiness are now essential to managing volatility, modernizing operations and meeting rising expectations for transparency and customer experience.
Future winners will drive customer‑centric growth through continuous transformation.
The Canadian insurance industry stands at a pivotal moment, shaped by global forces and a changing competitive landscape. Insurers in Canada face persistent volatility and uncertainty, driven by geopolitical tensions, macroeconomic uncertainty, demographic change, regulatory reform and shifting customer expectations. These challenges are compounded by climate-related risks, including wildfires, floods and severe storms, which continue to test resilience and claims capacity.
Snapshot of a market in flux
Canadian insurers are contending with the same structural shifts that are occurring globally:
Uncertainty and volatility are here to stay, requiring faster scenario modelling and decision-making. Trade volatility and supply chain sensitivity remain acute for Canada’s manufacturing, transportation and resource sectors, directly influencing commercial auto, cargo and specialty lines’ exposure. GDP growth is expected to remain modest into 2026, reinforcing a low-growth underwriting environment. This persistent volatility, driven by the macroeconomic instability, interest rate sensitivity, and shifting mortality trends is forcing insurers to strengthen enterprise risk management, adopt more agile capital allocation, and design more flexible and resilient products. Uncertainty is also influencing consumer behavior, adding complexity to demand forecasting and long-term planning.
Cost optimization is critical as softening cycles impact commercial lines and inflation squeezes margins, especially in auto repair costs. Rising catastrophe losses from wildfires and floods are increasing volatility in combined ratios, intensifying the need for disciplined expense management and reinsurance optimization. Insurers are increasingly looking beyond incremental efficiency gains toward structural cost transformation.
Embedding AI is a priority, pushing firms to rethink strategies beyond automation and efficiency alone and embedding AI within the broader business strategy and growth story. Canadian insurers are embedding AI across underwriting, pricing, claims, and customer service to improve speed, accuracy, and personalization. AI plays a critical role in meeting rising customer expectations—particularly among younger, digitally native consumers who expect seamless, intuitive, and responsive experiences. While some Canadian insurers are well underway, overall AI maturity lags global peers — most firms remain in pilot phases, and a recent EY survey found that only 30% of Canadian insurers report scaled AI deployments.
Regulatory landscape is evolving, adding complexity to insurers’ strategic planning. Two major auto insurance reforms in Ontario and Alberta are expected to reshape pricing models and operations. Regulators are intensifying scrutiny on emerging risks, including AI governance, data privacy, fairness in algorithmic decision-making and the MGA regulatory framework. IFRS 17 implementation continues to influence capital adequacy and reporting standards, demanding robust compliance frameworks. Climate-related disclosure requirements are expanding, with heightened expectations for transparency on risk management and resilience strategies.
The hunt for growth is intensifying, with Canadian carriers exploring partnerships, niche products (e.g., parametric) and tech-enabled distribution to augment organic premium growth expectations or pursuing M&A opportunities. Group benefits business is adding additional services while life and savings is seeking more flexible product structures to meet the changing needs of each new generation. Broker consolidation has accelerated in recent years and M&A continues to be a significant driver for growth, scale and diversification of distribution and exposures across insurers and intermediaries.
Learn more about our Financial Services teams and how they can help your business focus on delivering value while navigating risk and managing disruption.
Learn more about our Insurance team and how they can help your business navigate disruption, manage regulatory change and integrate technology to transform and achieve growth.
Strategic, tactical and competitive imperatives for 2026–27
To succeed in this environment, Canadian insurers must:
Sharpen capital and growth strategies, balancing portfolio decisions with disciplined risk management, creative partnerships and targeted investment in products that help close the protection gap and attract a new generation of customers.
Orient everything around customers, delivering modular products, personalized experiences and embedded solutions that meet evolving needs. In Canada’s broker-centric market, differentiation will increasingly depend on ease of doing business, real-time quoting and data-driven insights that strengthen broker relationships.
The winners will be insurers that build trust through fair, transparent pricing; deliver products that truly meet customer needs and rapidly resolve claims (including CAT events); provide human support when it matters; and design for resilience, such as rebuilding with fire‑ and flood‑resistant materials.
Embrace continuous transformation, integrating workforce strategies with technology adoption to build resilience and sustain innovation. Talent constraints, particularly in actuarial science, data, and underwriting and claims expertise, will require Canadian insurers to rethink workforce models, including nearshoring, upskilling and ecosystem partnerships.
Canadian insurers that prioritize customer-centric solutions, strengthen capital strategies and embed resilience into operations will not only navigate today’s turbulence but also lead in shaping the future.
For additional insights on the competitive environment and actionable strategies for how insurers can respond, we encourage you to review the Global Insurance Outlook linked below.
Canada’s insurance sector is navigating heightened pressure—from economic swings to climate‑driven losses and fast‑evolving customer needs. Sustained progress will depend on strengthening financial discipline, modernizing operations and advancing the use of data and AI. Firms that stay customer‑first, invest in adaptable capabilities and respond quickly to shifting risks will be best equipped to grow. The industry’s next phase belongs to insurers that treat uncertainty as a catalyst for smarter strategy and long‑term resilience.
Contributors
Jullie Hands, Partner, Insurance Consulting, EY Canada
