EY helps clients create long-term value for all stakeholders. Enabled by data and technology, our services and solutions provide trust through assurance and help clients transform, grow and operate.
At EY, our purpose is building a better working world. The insights and services we provide help to create long-term value for clients, people and society, and to build trust in the capital markets.
In this episode of the EY India Insights Podcast, Amish S. Mehta, Partner, Valuations, Modeling and Economics, EY India shares insights on contingent consideration and earn-out structures and how they can help buyers and sellers bridge valuation gaps to unlock successful mergers and acquisitions (M&A) outcomes. He discusses the key principles of designing effective earn-out mechanisms, including milestone setting, performance measurement, governance frameworks and payment timelines. Amish also highlights managing post-deal disputes and explains why these structures are likely to become increasingly important in an environment marked by valuation uncertainty and market volatility.
Key takeaways
Earn-out structures help bridge valuation gaps by aligning future payments with business performance, enabling buyers and sellers to reach agreement.
Successful earn-outs require clearly defined milestones, transparent calculation methodologies and well-documented payment timelines to reduce disputes.
Pre-agreed treatment of partial target achievement can help reduce disputes and create greater certainty for all transaction stakeholders.
Independent verification of performance milestones and robust contractual drafting are critical to mitigating post-deal disagreements.
As market volatility increases, innovative structures such as earn-outs are becoming valuable tools for overcoming valuation mismatches and closing deals.
Well-designed earn-outs require early stakeholder alignment and independent milestone verification to minimize disputes and build transaction confidence.
Amish S Mehta
Partner, Transactions and Corporate Finance, EY India
For your convenience, a full text transcript of this podcast is available on the link below:
Hello and welcome to the EY India Insights Podcast. I am Pallavi, your host for today and in today's episode, we discuss how contingent consideration and earn-out structures are helping businesses bridge valuation gaps and successfully close mergers and acquisitions (M&A) deals.
Amish, welcome to the podcast and thanks for joining us in this episode.
Amish
Thank you, Pallavi.
Pallavi
Valuation gaps remain one of the biggest reasons why M&A deals stall or fail. How can contingent consideration or earn-out structures help buyers and sellers bridge these differences and successfully close transactions?
Amish
Let us say the expectation of the seller who is selling a business is in the range of 100 to 120. But the buyer’s estimate of the business value is lower in the range of 60 to 80. As one can see, there is no overlapping range, so it is difficult to find a way to move forward. What contingent consideration does is that it makes these ranges wider to reduce the gap, creating a common ground for discussions between buyers and sellers.
In the same example, let us assume that the seller is promised something more in the future if certain events take place. Hence, they may be willing to pull down their expectation for base price that will get paid upfront, in the hope of being paid more later. On the other hand, a buyer would not mind paying more money in the future if the business which is being purchased performs exceedingly well.
So, this arrangement narrows the gap between the parties and creates the possibility of meeting of minds on the deal consideration.
Pallavi
What are the key factors that organizations should consider when designing an effective earn-out structure, particularly around performance metrics, timelines and governance?
Amish
There are three key factors that one should consider. The first one is: clearly identify the milestones. Second: agree upon the computation mechanism. For example, what to do if certain milestones are achieved but a few are missed. And the third one is: have precise timelines.
Let me elaborate on these a bit. If the milestone is profitability, say, achievement of a particular EBITDA number after two years, one could perhaps clarify in the agreement that the number should be audited or signed off by a chartered accountant, or at least a list of items which have to be excluded.
For example, some new initiatives undertaken by the buyer that contribute to the profitability may be excluded because there should not be an entitlement to the seller for these initiatives.
Secondly, in case the targets are achieved partially – top line growth is achieved but margins are missed – there should be a clear formula for computation so that there is no ambiguity later.
Lastly, the timelines should also mention clearly in the business transfer agreement or the sell and purchase of the agreement when this consideration would be paid. By what time should this measurement be completed so that everyone is clear about when the payment will be triggered?
Pallavi
Earn-outs can create significant value but they can also lead to post-deal disputes. What are the most common challenges and how can organizations proactively mitigate these risks?
Amish
Earn-out clauses are like any other contractual clauses. Lawyers and investment bankers should be involved at the initial drafting stage itself. Parties that generally have third-party processes, which in a way certifies the achievements of the milestones, reduce disputes in the future.
Pallavi
As market conditions continue to evolve, how do you see the role of earnout structures changing in the future of M&A transactions and what advice would you give business leaders evaluating this approach?
Amish
As uncertainty and volatility increase, there are more mismatches in expectations between buyers and sellers. We will see increasing use of earn-outs in deals, going forward. My advice to promoters, entrepreneurs and CXOs is that they should not shy away from trying innovative structures that can help negotiations move forward.
Pallavi
Thank you, Amish. Now that brings us to the end of this episode. Thank you so much again for your time and sharing all your insights and perspectives to all our listeners.
Amish
Thanks.
Pallavi
Thank you. And to all our listeners. Thanks for tuning in to the EY India Insights Podcast. We look forward to bringing you more conversation on the trends in shaping the future of business.
Until next time, thank you for listening. This is Pallavi, signing off.
Speaker
Amish S Mehta
Partner, Transactions and Corporate Finance, EY India
If you would like to listen to our podcasts on the go:
Discover M&A advisory services from EY when you buy and integrate. We help enable strategic growth through integrated mergers and acquisitions, joint ventures and alliances.
M&A Consulting services at EY helps to Perform portfolio review, assess businees strategy, due diligence & determine the right valuation & approach for funding
